Religion & Worldviews · Religion, history & society
The Reformation and religious authority
Follow a dispute about indulgences into larger questions about scripture, church authority and how religious arguments spread.

What you will learn
- Identify Luther's objection, in his 1517 theses, to confidence in indulgence letters.
- Explain why an early statement shouldn't be read as a complete account of the movement that came later.
- Explain how a dispute about a teaching can also become a dispute about who may interpret it.
- Tell shared criticism of Rome apart from agreement among reformers.
Lesson 1 of 4 · 4 min
What Luther's Ninety-five Theses objected to
"As soon as the money clinks into the money chest, the soul flies out of purgatory." That was the sales pitch, as Martin Luther reported it in 1517. Purgatory, in Catholic teaching, is where souls are purified after death.
What was for sale was an indulgence, a church grant that cut that time short. A friar named Johann Tetzel was selling them in Germany that year, and buyers got a letter as proof.
Luther, a monk and professor, wrote ninety-five short arguments against the trade. His worry was what a purchased letter did to the buyer's soul.
Luther's target was the preachers' promise. Thesis 32 says people who think an indulgence letter makes them certain of salvation "will be eternally damned, together with their teachers."
His alternative was genuine repentance. Thesis 36 says any truly repentant Christian already has full remission of penalty and guilt, "even without indulgence letters."
Thesis 86 passes on a question he says ordinary people were asking. Why doesn't the pope build St. Peter's basilica "with his own money rather than with the money of poor believers"?
The same document is loyal to the pope. Thesis 71 curses anyone who "speaks against the truth concerning papal indulgences." Thesis 38 says papal remission and blessing "are by no means to be disregarded."
Luther blamed the salesmen. Thesis 50 claims that if the pope knew what the indulgence preachers were demanding, he'd rather see St. Peter's "burned to ashes" than built with the "skin, flesh, and bones of his sheep."
Remember whose account this is. The theses show what Luther opposed. They aren't a neutral record of Catholic teaching.
The loyalty didn't last, because Rome replied. In 1518 church authorities summoned Luther and ordered him to take his position back. He refused. In 1521 he was excommunicated, shut out of the life of the church.
The argument widened to salvation, scripture, sacraments and the authority of popes and councils.
So the 1517 theses can't stand in for what Luther later held, let alone for other reformers.
Try to recallWhy would it be misleading to use only Luther's 1517 theses to describe all later Protestant teachings?
The theses record one writer's position at one stage. In 1517 Luther attacked the selling of indulgences and still upheld papal blessing. His views widened after Rome condemned him, and other reformers and communities took different positions.
Lessons in this topic
What Luther's Ninety-five Theses objected to
Luther's 1517 theses attack a sales pitch for indulgences. They're also far more loyal to the pope than the movement they started.
Who decides what the Bible means?
Luther and Zwingli read the same sentence of the Bible and couldn't agree. See why putting scripture first still left the question of whose reading counts.
How cheap pamphlets carried Luther's argument
Short German pamphlets took Luther's case far beyond scholars. The church used the same presses, and a surviving copy can't tell you whether its owner agreed.
When a prince chose his subjects' church
The 1555 Peace of Augsburg let each German prince pick Catholic or Lutheran for his whole territory. See why it left out the groups who denied rulers that power.
Three quick stories from this topic
The loyal Ninety-five Theses
Luther's Ninety-five Theses curse anyone who speaks against papal indulgences
"Anathema and accursed" is the phrase in thesis 71. In 1517 Luther's target was the preachers who promised that a coin in the chest freed a soul from purgatory. He wrote as if the pope were on his side. Four years later he was excommunicated.
The sales pitch he attacked
Thesis 27 quotes it. As soon as the money clinks into the money chest, the soul flies out of purgatory. Luther called that a merely human doctrine.
Why the loyalty ended
Church authorities ordered Luther to take his position back, and he refused. The argument widened to scripture and the pope's authority, and in 1521 he was excommunicated.
Indulgences off the press
Printers mass-produced indulgences long before they printed Luther's attack on them
A printed indulgence was a single sheet with a blank space for the buyer's name. Printers liked the steady orders from the church, and 90% of the printed indulgences surviving from the 1400s were made in Germany. Luther's cheap pamphlets then became their next success.
Flying writings
Luther's pamphlets were short, cheap and often in German, and a printer could turn one out in days. For many families, one of them was the first book they owned.
Copies don't count converts
A surviving pamphlet shows that it circulated. Whether its owner agreed takes other evidence, such as the notes a reader left in the margins.
Whose realm, his religion
After 1555, a German prince's choice of church became his subjects' church too
The Peace of Augsburg offered two options, Catholic or Lutheran, and the ruler picked for the whole territory. The rule is summed up as "whose realm, his religion." Subjects who refused could move away, and groups outside the two churches had no protection.
How the map divided
The emperor Charles V had opposed Protestantism, yet the settlement was reached. Many northern German rulers became Lutheran, while Austria and Bavaria, in the south, stayed Catholic. Luther had earlier urged the German princes to reject the pope's authority, and rulers often welcomed the chance.
Two options only
The settlement made room for no religions except Catholic and Lutheran. Anabaptists, who rejected rulers' control over religion, were widely feared and attacked, and wars of religion continued into the seventeenth century.
Sources
- Martin Luther: Ninety-five Theses, 1517, English translation, Fordham University Internet History Sourcebooks
- 5.1 The Protestant Reformation - World History Volume 2, from 1400 | OpenStax, OpenStax
- Religious Change and Print Culture in the Reformation, Newberry Library
- Peace of Augsburg, Wikimedia Foundation





