Mind & Psychology · Personality & development
Traits, situations and behavior
See why psychologists describe personality as positions on five scales, how the situation shapes what a trait looks like in action, and how to judge a personality test.

What you will learn
- Describe a personality trait as a tendency measured along a dimension
- Explain why a trait doesn't predict every action
- Pick out the person, the behavior and the context in a social-cognitive account
- Explain how behavior can also change the situation
Lesson 1 of 4 · 4 min
Why personality comes in degrees, not types
English has about 4,500 words for what people are like. The psychologist Gordon Allport counted them in the 1930s. Shy, loyal, grouchy, bold. If each word named a separate kind of person, nobody could keep track.
Trait psychology takes another route. It treats a trait such as extraversion as a general tendency that people have more or less of. So you can love a lively dinner on Friday and want a quiet evening on Saturday. A tendency isn't a rule for every night.
Later researchers boiled the list down. Raymond Cattell cut it to 16 dimensions. The most popular model today has five, the Big Five. They are openness, conscientiousness, extraversion, agreeableness and neuroticism.
Each one is a scale from low to high, and everybody has a place on all five. A questionnaire asks you to rate statements such as "I am the life of the party" from strongly disagree to strongly agree. Your answers add up to a score on each scale.
Most people land near the middle. So calling someone "an extravert" or "an introvert" cuts a continuous scale into two boxes and throws away where they actually sit.
Your position on those scales is fairly stable, and it gets more stable with age. A review of 152 long-term studies checked how well people kept their rank against others over about seven years. A score of 1 would mean nobody's rank changed. In childhood the figure was .31. At age 30 it was .64. It leveled off around .74 between 50 and 70.
So personality firms up for decades and never fully sets.
A stable tendency also leaves room for variation from moment to moment. A talkative person goes quiet while following a hard explanation. A reserved person talks at length about a subject they love. Neither is acting out of character.
So choose words that fit what a trait is. "Often seeks company" describes a tendency and survives a quiet weekend. "Always wants company" is a rule, and one exception breaks it.
The same goes for judging other people. A pattern you've seen many times tells you something about a trait. One meeting tells you very little.
Try to recallWhy doesn't one quiet meeting prove that a person has no tendency toward extraversion?
A trait describes a general pattern or degree, not every single action. That meeting may have brought its own demands or preferences, so one observation can't settle the broader tendency.
A trait is a position on a scale. It holds fairly steady across adult life and tilts the odds of how you'll act. It doesn't decide any single evening.
Lessons in this topic
Why personality comes in degrees, not types
See how psychologists got from thousands of words for character to five scales, and why your place on a scale doesn't script any single evening.
Why the same person acts differently in different rooms
A review of decades of research found that traits don't show up the same way in every situation. See how the person, the action and the setting shape one another.
What a personality profile can and can't tell you
Learn to read a set of Big Five scores as positions in a comparison group, and see how those positions shift across a lifetime.
Does a personality test measure anything?
Two questions sort good personality tests from bad ones. Is the test consistent, and does it measure what it claims? See how questionnaires and inkblots compare.
Three quick stories from this topic
A test built on Minnesota farmers
A famous personality test began with mostly Minnesota farmers and psychiatric patients
The MMPI came out in 1943 with 504 true-or-false questions. A personality score only means something next to the group it's compared with, so in 1989 the test was rebuilt on a more representative national sample.
Why the comparison group matters
A personality score only means something compared with a reference group. The 1989 revision, the MMPI-2, had 567 questions and was based on a more representative national sample, which allowed better standardization. A 2008 version, the MMPI-2-RF, uses 338 questions.
Norms don't travel well
Any instrument built on data from one population can misdescribe people from other populations. Test bias has limited the use of traditional projective tests across cultures for the same reason. Before you read a profile, ask who the test was standardized on.
Agreeableness and pay
Men who score low on agreeableness earn more than agreeable men, one study found
Agreeableness is one of the Big Five personality traits, and covers being cooperative, trusting and good-natured. Across four studies published in 2012, more agreeable people earned less. The link was stronger for men than for women.
A trait is a scale
In the Big Five model everyone has a position on five scales, from low to high. A low score describes a tendency. It doesn't count against a person.
A proposed reason
The researchers' fourth study, an experiment, pointed to backlash against agreeable men, who don't fit conventional expectations of how men behave.
When personality settles
Personality is least stable in childhood and keeps firming up until about age 50
A review of 152 long-term studies tracked how well people kept their rank on personality traits over about seven years. The match was .31 in childhood and .64 at age 30. It leveled off near .74 between 50 and 70. A perfect match would be 1.
Rank and level
The review measured rank, such as whether the more outgoing child is still the more outgoing adult. Average levels move too. People tend to grow more conscientious and emotionally stable between 20 and 40.
Never fully fixed
Even at its most stable, the figure stays well below 1. Traits hold fairly steady in later adulthood and still leave room for change.
Sources
- Trait Theorists, OpenStax, Psychology 2e
- Learning Approaches, OpenStax, Psychology 2e
- The rank-order consistency of personality traits from childhood to old age: a quantitative review of longitudinal studies, Psychological Bulletin (PubMed record)
- Personality Assessment, OpenStax, Psychology 2e
- Do nice guys--and gals--really finish last? The joint effects of sex and agreeableness on income, Judge, Livingston and Hurst, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 2012 (PubMed record)
- Patterns of mean-level change in personality traits across the life course: a meta-analysis of longitudinal studies, Psychological Bulletin (PubMed record)





