Mind & Psychology · Relationships & social behavior
Conformity and dissent
Why people go along with a group or an authority, what Asch's and Milgram's experiments found, and what makes it easier to disagree.

What you will learn
- Tell conforming to fit in apart from conforming because others seem to know more
- Explain why agreeing out loud doesn't reveal what someone privately believes
- Use the features of a situation to judge which kind of influence is more likely
- Describe the role of the planted group members in Asch's line task
- Explain why a study's conformity rate isn't a fixed measure of how everyone behaves
- Explain what an experiment's manipulation lets you conclude, and why everyday agreement doesn't
Lesson 1 of 4 · 6 min
Two reasons people go along with a group
You're watching a film in a movie theater when something that looks like smoke drifts in under the exit door. It might be a fire. It might be a fog machine in the film. So you do what most people do, and look at everyone else.
If the crowd gets up to leave, you'll probably leave too. If nobody moves, you'll stay in your seat. You're treating other people as a source of knowledge. Psychologists call that informational influence.
There's a second reason to follow a group. You can go along to be accepted, even when you think the group is wrong. That's normative influence.
What separates the two is the reason for going along. With informational influence you change your mind, because the group seems better informed. With normative influence you can privately doubt the group's answer and say it anyway. A single situation can involve both motives at once.
A classroom shows the second kind. A teacher asks the children to vote out loud for extra recess, no homework or candy. Once a few have voted, the rest tend to vote the same way. In another classroom the first few might choose differently, and that class would follow them instead.
So agreeing in public doesn't tell you what someone believes in private. The words are the same whether the person was persuaded or just didn't want to stand out.
One test is to take the audience away. When people write their answers down privately instead of saying them aloud, they conform less often. Some of the agreement was for the audience.
A secret ballot works on the same principle. Nobody sees your vote, so nobody can pressure you into it or punish you for it.
Following others isn't foolish. It makes sense when they know something relevant, as the people sitting nearest that theater exit might. What matters is whether their information is dependable and whether anyone could have disagreed freely.
A crowd isn't automatically wrong, and a dissenter isn't automatically right. Once you can tell which kind of influence is at work, you can weigh the reasons behind an agreement instead of praising or blaming the agreement itself.
Try to recallWhy might two people give the same answer as their group while privately believing different things?
One may think the group has better information and accept its answer. The other may still doubt the answer but go along to be accepted or to avoid conflict. The public answer alone can't tell you which motive is at work.
You can't read a motive off a single act, but the situation narrows it down. Informational influence is more likely when the judgment is genuinely hard or the evidence is thin, and when the others have some claim to know more. Normative influence is more likely when the judgment is easy, the answer is given in public and disagreeing carries a social cost.
You can check all of those conditions without claiming to know what anyone privately thinks.
Picture the same meeting run twice. In the first version, a new colleague sits through an argument about an ambiguous set of figures and ends up agreeing with the team's reading. The material is unclear and the others have handled it for years, so treating their view as evidence is reasonable.
In the second version, the colleague spots an obvious error on a slide, hears six people call it fine and says nothing. The task is easy, so the real question is what disagreeing would have cost.
The two kinds of influence can work together. A person can think the group is probably right and also prefer not to be the only objector.
The distinction still matters, because each kind calls for a different response. If the influence is informational, the fix is better evidence. If it's normative, the fix is to lower the cost of disagreeing, for example by collecting views privately before anyone says them aloud.
So when a group agrees, ask two things. Was the question hard enough that people needed each other's knowledge? And could anyone have disagreed freely? The theater crowd passes the first test. The classroom vote fails the second.
Lessons in this topic
Two reasons people go along with a group
Tell going along to fit in from going along because the group seems to know more, and see why each one calls for a different fix.
What Asch's line experiment really found
See how Solomon Asch set up his conformity experiment, what its numbers say and why it supports a claim that an ordinary meeting can't.
How a group silences doubts, and how to hear them
See how a group can look unanimous while its members hold back, and which meeting procedure removes which pressure.
What made people refuse in Milgram's shock experiment
Tell obedience to an authority from conformity to a group, then use Milgram's variations to predict what makes people more likely to refuse.
Three quick stories from this topic
Kennedy left the room
Kennedy stayed out of some Cuban missile crisis meetings so he wouldn't sway his advisers
A year earlier his team had approved the failed Bay of Pigs invasion, and one adviser had played down his own doubts. In 1962, by the psychologist Irving Janis's account, Kennedy also brought in outside experts and split his advisers into smaller groups.
The Bay of Pigs lesson
Janis made the 1961 invasion his main example of groupthink, where keeping a group in agreement crowds out a hard look at the plan.
Why the leader speaks last
A leader who states a preference first makes other answers harder to give. Scholars still argue over how much groupthink explains the Bay of Pigs.
One ally is enough
In Asch's line experiment, one person giving the right answer cut conformity to a quarter
Solomon Asch seated a student among actors who all named the wrong line, and students followed them on about a third of their answers. When one actor answered correctly instead, wrong answers fell to a quarter of that rate. A group loses most of its pull once it isn't unanimous.
An easy question
Left to themselves, people matched the lines wrongly less than 1% of the time. The lines were easy, so the errors came from the group.
Fitting in, not being fooled
People who went along didn't accept the wrong answer in private. They gave it to fit in and avoid ridicule, and an ally meant they no longer stood alone.
The one-in-a-thousand guess
Psychiatrists predicted 1 in 1,000 people would give Milgram's top shock, and 65% did
Stanley Milgram asked 40 psychiatrists how far volunteers would go when an experimenter told them to keep shocking a stranger. The shocks were fake, but the volunteers didn't know. The setup mattered more than the people. When the orders came by phone, the rate fell to 23%.
What volunteers were told
They believed they were giving a learner electric shocks for wrong answers, in 15-volt steps up to 450 volts. The learner was an actor who cried out and begged them to stop.
What lowered obedience
Fewer people obeyed when the learner sat in the same room, and fewer still when they had to touch him. When two other "teachers" refused, only 4 of 40 went on.
Sources
- Conformity, compliance, and obedience, OpenStax / Rice University
- Groupthink, Wikimedia Foundation
- Opinions and social pressure, Scientific American, November 1955 (scan at the Internet Archive)
- Milgram experiment, Wikimedia Foundation





