History · Archaeology & historical evidence
How historians read a source
History is built from sources made by people with their own aims. Learn to ask who made a source, when, for whom and why, and what historians do when sources disagree, fall silent or get rewritten.

What you will learn
- Use who, when, for whom and why to judge what a source can be trusted to tell you
- Explain how a slanted source can still give trustworthy evidence by accident
- Explain how historians use independent sources to check each other
- Explain why silence and lost records limit what surviving sources can prove
Lesson 1 of 4 · 4 min
Four questions to ask any source
In 58 BCE, Julius Caesar says he found a census in an enemy camp. Written in Greek on tablets, it counted 263,000 Helvetii and 105,000 allies, and exactly a quarter were fighters. Should you believe him?
Caesar's account is a primary source, something made at the time you're studying. Historians start with four questions. Who made it? Caesar, the commander, writing about himself in the third person. When? During or soon after the war, published by 46 BCE.
For whom? Roman readers back home. Why? To make his war look justified and his wins look huge. The historian David Henige notes that Caesar was the aggressor, though he claimed to be defending Rome.
So the census looks shaky. Why would Gauls keep records in Greek, or haul piles of tablets on a migration? And a neat quarter is suspiciously convenient. The questions don't throw the source out. They tell you which parts lean toward what its author needed.
A slanted source still tells you things its author never meant to say. The historian Louis Gottschalk gave an example. A Roman road inscription says a certain governor built the road while Augustus ruled.
You might doubt the governor did the building, since officials liked credit. It's much harder to doubt that the road existed under Augustus. Nobody had a reason to fake that part. Historians call this kind of detail incidental evidence.
Gottschalk's second example was an advert boasting about a brand of coffee at an unusual price. Doubt the boast if you like. The advert still proves the brand existed. So you trust each statement separately, by asking whether the author gained anything from it.
Try to recallA Roman inscription credits a governor with building a road during Augustus's reign. Why might a historian doubt the credit but trust the date?
Officials gained prestige from claiming public works, so the governor's credit may be inflated. Nobody gained anything by placing the road in Augustus's reign, so that incidental detail is much harder to doubt.
Ask who made a source, when, for whom and why, and you'll see which claims lean toward the author's aims. Then look for the details nobody had a reason to invent, because those are often the most trustworthy.
Lessons in this topic
Four questions to ask any source
See how historians judge a source by who made it, when, for whom and why, and how even a slanted source gives away facts by accident.
When sources disagree, or stay silent
Learn how historians test one source against another, why copies don't count as extra witnesses, and what to make of silence and lost records.
Reading a king's own account of himself
Read Darius's cliff inscription and Augustus's list of his deeds as boasts with a purpose, and see what comparing them with other sources reveals.
Why history gets rewritten, and when it's denial
See how new finds and new questions change what historians say, and what separates honest revision from denial that bends the evidence.
Three quick stories from this topic
A boast on a cliff
Darius had his life story carved about 100 meters up a cliff above a royal road
The Behistun inscription is about 15 meters tall and written in three languages. Darius sent the text out in copies too, and one in Aramaic turned up in Egypt.
Written for the future
The text tells future readers to believe it and not to hold it to be lies. It also curses anyone who destroys the carving.
Why historians doubt it
Darius says he killed an impostor posing as the old king's brother. Most modern historians think the man he killed was the real prince.
The pharaoh's disputed victory
A Hittite king complained in writing about the pharaoh's claim to have won at Kadesh
Ramesses II carved his victory at Kadesh on temple after temple in Egypt. Hittite records say he left in defeat, and a letter from Ramesses answers the Hittite king Hattusili III's complaint about his boasts.
Two sides, two endings
Egypt's carvings show the pharaoh charging the enemy and saving the day. Records from the Hittite capital, Hattusa, say he went home beaten.
What both agree on
Ramesses didn't take Kadesh, and the land near it was Hittite again within a year. Most historians call the battle a practical draw.
A Roman birthday invitation
A birthday invitation from about AD 100 may be the oldest Latin writing by a woman
Claudia Severa invited her friend Sulpicia Lepidina to a party at a fort near Hadrian's Wall. A scribe wrote most of the wooden tablet, and Severa added the closing greeting in her own hand.
Mistaken for shavings
The Vindolanda tablets were first taken for wood shavings in 1973. The ink faded in the air, so infrared photographs were needed to read it.
Why it matters
Letters like this put wives, friends and parties into the story of a frontier known mostly through soldiers. New evidence like this is one reason history gets rewritten.
Sources
- Commentarii de Bello Gallico, Wikipedia
- Historical method, Wikipedia
- Reading Like a Historian, Digital Inquiry Group (formerly Stanford History Education Group)
- Primary source, Wikipedia
- Behistun inscription, Wikipedia
- Battle of Kadesh, Wikipedia
- Vindolanda tablets, Wikipedia





