Arts & Culture · Visual art & craft
Learning to look at a painting
Go beyond naming the objects in a picture. See how Goya, Bouts, Van Dyck and Vernet used empty space, color, surface and line, then build a reading from what you can point to.

What you will learn
- Describe how the arrangement of a painting can guide your attention
- Tell a feature you observe apart from your interpretation of its effect
- Tell hue, value and intensity apart when describing a color
- Explain how a color's surroundings affect its role in a composition
Lesson 1 of 4 · 4 min
How a painting steers your eye
Around 1820 Francisco Goya drew a very old man hobbling along on two canes. The drawing is in the Getty Museum, and there's very little in it. Goya put the man low on the page and left the rest of the sheet blank.
The Getty's reading is that the empty paper suggests his loneliness. Goya only chose where the man sits and how much nothing surrounds him. That arrangement of the visible parts is called the composition, and describing it is where looking at art starts.
Now take a made-up painting. One person stands beside a window, and a table juts in from the edge. The table's edge makes a diagonal line, and a line like that can lead your eye along it to the figure.
Beside the figure is a wide stretch of empty wall. The area around a main subject is called negative space. It can look like leftover background, but it's part of the arrangement. A lot of it can make a figure seem isolated, which is what Goya's blank paper does.
Description and interpretation work together, but they aren't the same thing. "The person takes up a small area at the left" describes placement. "The person seems vulnerable" interprets its effect. A good interpretation shows how you got from one to the other.
It also takes the rest of the picture into account. A small figure in a busy celebration feels quite different from a small figure alone in a large, bare room. What matters is what surrounds it.
You can test a reading by changing the picture in your head. Imagine the window painting with the figure enlarged and centered. The visual relationships have changed, and most of the isolation goes with the empty wall.
If changing a feature changes your response, that feature was doing the work. You don't need to guess at an artist's private intentions. Start with what's visible, describe the relationship and say why it matters to your reading.
Try to recallHow could you support a claim that a painted figure seems isolated without claiming to know the artist's intention?
Point to visible features, such as the figure's small size, the empty space around it or the lack of other figures nearby. Then explain how those relationships support the reading.
Next time a picture makes you feel something, look for the cause on its surface. Ask where the subject sits, which lines lead to it and how much empty space surrounds it. Goya's old man is small and low on the page, and the rest is blank.
Lessons in this topic
How a painting steers your eye
Where things sit, which lines lead to them and how much empty space surrounds them all shape how a picture feels. Learn to describe that, and to keep what you see apart from what you make of it.
What the word red leaves out
A color has a hue, a value and an intensity. Learn to tell them apart, and see why the same red can shout in one picture and vanish in another.
How flat paint passes for silk and deep space
A painting has a physical surface of its own, separate from the textures and depth it shows. Learn to describe both without mixing them up.
Why a tilted ship looks like it's moving
Vernet painted a calm harbor and a stormy one as a pair. Comparing them shows how line direction supports a reading of rest or motion, and where that support stops.
Three quick stories from this topic
Goya's lonely blank page
Goya made an old man look lonely by placing him low on an almost empty page
The drawing, He Can No Longer at the Age of 98, shows a man hobbling on two canes. Goya left the paper around him blank. Artists call that area negative space, and the Getty says here it suggests the man's loneliness.
Positive and negative space
The space the main subjects occupy is positive space, and the area around them is negative space. In Goya's drawing the man and his shadow are the positive space.
Point to what you see
A reading like loneliness is strongest when you can name the visible feature behind it, such as a small figure with a lot of empty space around it.
Silk made of paint
Painting fabric convincingly was one of the marks of a great painter in the 1600s
Van Dyck's 1621 portrait of the ambassador Agostino Pallavicini shows why. His red silk robes spread across the canvas, and the Getty says they almost threaten to take over the painting. The sheen is only color, line and shading on a flat surface.
Implied texture
Implied texture is the visual suggestion of how a pictured surface would feel. The Getty's guide uses Van Dyck's robe, painted to simulate silk, as its example.
Two textures at once
The paint has its own actual texture, which may be smooth, rough or raised. So a rough painted surface can show a smooth object.
Why a leaning ship looks in motion
A leaning ship in a painting reads as motion because tilted things are falling or moving
Vernet used this in a pair of harbor scenes now at the Getty. The storm of 1767 is full of diagonals, from the battered ship to the rocks. The calm of 1770 is built on level lines, which suggest rest because things lying flat are at rest.
Horizontals in one, diagonals in the other
In the calm, Getty points to horizontal lines that divide the landscape into sections receding into space and imply that the scene continues beyond the frame. In the storm, it points to the angles of the ship and the rocks on the shore, which it reads as conveying movement because tilted objects are falling or in motion.
Useful support, short of proof
Getty's readings rest on a reason, which is that objects parallel to the ground are usually at rest. That makes line direction useful support for an interpretation, though it can't prove a single response. Other features, such as value and color, need to be read alongside it.
Sources
- Elements of art: Understanding formal analysis, Getty Education
- He Can No Longer at the Age of Ninety-Eight, Francisco de Goya, The J. Paul Getty Museum, on Google Arts & Culture
- Portrait of Agostino Pallavicini, Anthony van Dyck, The J. Paul Getty Museum, on Google Arts & Culture
- A Storm on a Mediterranean Coast, information for teaching, J. Paul Getty Museum, Education
- A Calm at a Mediterranean Port, information for teaching, J. Paul Getty Museum, Education





