Guide · Ways of learning
What are T-shaped skills?
T-shaped skills are deep expertise in one field combined with working knowledge of many others. The vertical bar of the T stands for the depth and the horizontal bar for the breadth. A T-shaped person can do expert work in a specialty and still collaborate with people outside it, which is why employers use the term in hiring.
The idea is older than most articles say, and its best-known champion did not invent it. This guide covers the origin, what each bar means, examples by job, the pi-shaped and comb-shaped variants, how to build your own horizontal bar, and where the model falls short.
What does T-shaped mean?
The vertical bar is the easy part. It is the thing you are trained in and could be hired for, such as structural engineering, tax law or interaction design.
The horizontal bar has two meanings, and sources mix them. Valve, the game company, defines it as knowledge. Its 2012 handbook for new employees says T-shaped people are generalists who are "highly skilled at a broad set of valuable things" and also experts who are "among the best in their field within a narrow discipline."
Tim Brown, then chief executive of the design firm IDEO, defined it as attitude. In a 2010 interview he called the horizontal stroke "the disposition for collaboration across disciplines" and tied it to empathy, which lets people "imagine the problem from another perspective."
The two readings fit together. You work well with an accountant when you know enough accounting to understand their constraints and care enough to ask.
Where did the term T-shaped person come from?
Many pages credit Tim Brown with coining the term. The record is longer than that.
- 1978. An article by D. L. Johnston in IEEE Engineering Management Review, about scientists who become managers, had "the T-shaped man" in its title.
- 1980s. McKinsey & Company is reported to have used "T-shaped man" internally when recruiting and developing consultants.
- 1991. David Guest wrote about the idea in The Independent on 17 September 1991, under the headline "The hunt is on for the Renaissance Man of computing". This is usually cited as the first popular reference.
- 2001. Morten Hansen and Bolko von Oetinger published "Introducing T-Shaped Managers" in Harvard Business Review, based on BP Amoco. Their T-shaped managers "share knowledge freely across their organization" while staying committed to the results of their own business unit.
- 2010. Brown described IDEO's preference for T-shaped hires in an interview with Chief Executive magazine. Many later articles credit him with the term.
- 2012. Valve's handbook told new staff that the company values "T-shaped" people.
What are examples of T-shaped skills by job?
These are illustrations. The right mix depends on the team around you.
| Job | Vertical bar | Horizontal bar |
|---|---|---|
| Software engineer | Backend systems in one language | Product design basics, data analysis, security, clear writing |
| Product designer | Interaction design | User research, front-end code, business metrics |
| Marketer | Search engine optimization | Copywriting, analytics, basic statistics, sales |
| Data analyst | Statistics and SQL | Knowledge of the business, visualization, presenting to non-specialists |
| Lawyer | Contract law | Finance basics, negotiation, the client's industry |
What does a T-shaped professional do differently?
A T-shaped professional in any of these jobs does two things more easily than a narrow specialist. They notice when a problem belongs to another discipline, and they can explain their own work to that discipline in plain terms.
Brown's warning about the alternative is blunt. When people with only individual skills work on the same problem, each discipline defends its own view, and the result is what he called "gray compromises".
What are I-shaped, pi-shaped and comb-shaped skills?
| Shape | What it means |
|---|---|
| I-shaped | Deep skill in one field and little outside it. |
| Generalist, with no vertical bar | Broad knowledge with no deep skill. Valve wrote that "a generalist who doesn't go deep enough in a single area ends up on the margins". |
| T-shaped | One deep skill plus broad working knowledge. |
| Pi-shaped | Two deep skills under one broad bar, like the Greek letter. The Scrum Alliance describes it as "two or more areas of deep expertise and a broad range of supporting skills". |
| M-shaped and comb-shaped | Several deep skills. A 2020 article from AXELOS says that with more than three specialties, the M turns into a comb. |
Do the other shapes matter?
None of these shapes is a research category. They are informal labels, and agreement thins out past pi-shaped.
The useful point behind the variants is that one deep skill is sometimes too few. A designer who also codes, or a biologist who also programs, covers work that would otherwise need two people.
How to build the horizontal bar
Most people already have the start of a vertical bar from training and work. The horizontal bar is usually what is missing, and it costs far less time to build than depth does.
- Map your neighbors. List the people who hand you work and the people who receive yours. Their fields come first.
- Learn vocabulary and core ideas, not the craft. Valve's handbook tells its engineers that "the more you can learn about the mechanics, vocabulary, and analysis within other disciplines, the more valuable you become."
- Do one small real task in a neighboring field. Write the brief, read the contract or run the query. An hour of doing shows you what the textbook left out.
- Read outside work altogether. History, economics, psychology and statistics come up in nearly every job, and a broad catalogue of subjects is an easy place to start.
- Explain your specialty to outsiders. If you cannot do it without jargon, the Feynman technique will show you where your own understanding is thin.
- Review what you learn. Knowledge you never use fades, and spaced repetition is a cheap way to keep it.
What about the vertical bar?
Keep feeding it. Depth needs long, focused practice, and nothing on the list above replaces that. Our guide to breadth vs depth covers the evidence on how to split your time.
What are the critiques of the T-shaped model?
- It is vague. Nobody says how deep the vertical bar must be or how wide the horizontal one, and the horizontal bar means knowledge in one source and attitude in another.
- Its evidence is thin. The best-known sources are a magazine interview, an employee handbook and a management article about one company. None of them offers a way to measure how T-shaped a person is.
- One bar may be too few. The pi-shaped and comb-shaped variants exist because a single specialty can leave you exposed when a field changes.
- It can be used to stretch jobs. "Be more T-shaped" sometimes means "cover a second role for the same pay". Breadth helps you work with other specialists. It does not make you one of them.
Is the T-shaped model still useful?
Yes, as a planning tool. It asks two good questions, which are what you are deep in and what you know around it. Most people can answer the first and have never thought about the second. For the wider debate, see generalist vs specialist.
Where Generalist fits
Generalist works on the horizontal bar. The app has 976 short lessons across 16 subjects, each taking 3 to 7 minutes, and its review sessions bring back questions from lessons you have finished. It does not build the vertical bar. That still takes years of practice in your own field.
Common questions
What is a T-shaped person?
A T-shaped person has deep expertise in one field, the vertical bar of the T, and working knowledge of many related fields, the horizontal bar. The depth lets them do expert work. The breadth lets them understand and collaborate with specialists in other disciplines.
Who came up with T-shaped skills?
The origin is unclear. A 1978 engineering management article had "the T-shaped man" in its title, and McKinsey is reported to have used the phrase in the 1980s. David Guest brought it to newspaper readers in 1991, and Tim Brown of IDEO later made it widely known.
What is the difference between T-shaped and pi-shaped skills?
A T-shaped person has one area of deep expertise under a broad bar of general knowledge. A pi-shaped person has two, like the two legs of the Greek letter. Examples are a designer who can also write production code, or a biologist with deep programming skills.
What is an example of T-shaped skills?
A marketer who is an expert in search engine optimization and also understands copywriting, analytics, basic statistics and how the sales team works. The SEO expertise is the vertical bar. The surrounding knowledge is the horizontal bar that lets them work with writers, analysts and salespeople.
Is it better to be T-shaped or a specialist?
For most team-based work, T-shaped is the safer choice. Valve's handbook says that an expert who is too narrow has difficulty collaborating, and that a generalist without depth ends up on the margins. In solo fields with stable rules, such as chess, depth matters most.
Sources
- T-shaped skills, Wikipedia
- IDEO CEO Tim Brown: T-Shaped Stars: The Backbone of IDEO's Collaborative Culture (21 January 2010), Chief Executive
- Hansen and von Oetinger (2001). Introducing T-Shaped Managers: Knowledge Management's Next Generation, Harvard Business Review
- Valve Handbook for New Employees (first edition, 2012), Valve Corporation
- What Are Pi-Shaped Work Skills?, Scrum Alliance
- What employee type or shape are you? (AXELOS, August 2020), AXELOS, republished by WiredGov