Guide · Ways of learning
The full quote behind "jack of all trades, master of none"
"Jack of all trades, master of none" describes a person who can do many things passably and is expert in none of them. The popular "full quote" adds "but oftentimes better than a master of one". That ending is a modern addition with no early source, and Shakespeare wrote neither version.
The documented history is better than the myth. It starts with an insult aimed at Shakespeare in 1592, passes through a debtors' prison and a Dublin pamphlet about druggists, and ends with a hopeful rewrite in our own century.
What is the full quote?
The version people share is "A jack of all trades is a master of none, but oftentimes better than a master of one." It usually arrives with the claim that this is the original saying and that the last line was cut to turn praise into an insult.
The record shows the opposite. Wiktionary dates the couplet to the 21st century and calls it rare. Wikipedia's entry says the evidence points to a recent development. The Phrase Finder, which follows the saying through its early centuries in print, gives the full quote as "Jack of all trades, master of none" and stops there. None of the printed examples from the 1600s and 1700s contains a line about being better than a master of one.
So the saying grew in the unflattering direction. "Jack of all trades" came first. "Master of none" was bolted on more than a century later. The cheerful ending arrived more than 250 years after that.
Did Shakespeare say jack of all trades, master of none?
No. Goodreads carries the long version under his name, on a page that says its quotes are added by users and are not verified. A search of the Complete Works of William Shakespeare on Project Gutenberg finds no "jack of all trades" and no "master of none" in any play or poem.
The real link is that a version of the phrase was thrown at him. In 1592 a pamphlet called Greene's Groats-worth of Witte warned playwrights about an actor who had started writing plays. It called him "an upstart Crow, beautified with our feathers", "an absolute Johannes fac totum" and, in his own opinion, "the onely Shake-scene in a countrey". Most scholars agree the target was Shakespeare.
Johannes fac totum means roughly "Johnny do-everything". Fac totum is Latin for "do all" and is the source of the English word factotum. The complaint was snobbery. An actor without a university education thought he could write blank verse as well as the university men.
Even the author is uncertain. The pamphlet was registered on 20 September 1592, less than three weeks after Robert Greene died. The printer Henry Chettle prepared it for the press, and some scholars think he wrote part or all of it.
Where does jack of all trades come from?
Jack is the everyday form of John, and by the 14th century it meant any ordinary man. The Phrase Finder cites John Gower's poem Confessio Amantis, from 1390, for that sense. Lumberjacks, steeplejacks and jack-tars carry the same name.
The English phrase first appears in Geffray Minshull's Essayes and Characters of a Prison and Prisoners, where a prison porter is "some broken Citizen, who hath plaid Iack of all trades". The Phrase Finder dates this to 1612. That looks like a slip. The Dictionary of National Biography records that Minshull was jailed for debt in 1617 and published the essays in 1618, and Merriam-Webster gives 1618 as the first known use.
The Phrase Finder says the words carried no negative sense at first. The quotation itself points the other way. Minshull's Jack is a bankrupt who has drifted through several jobs and ended up minding a prison door. That is hardly praise.
When was master of none added?
Writers spent the next century attaching a put-down to the phrase, with a different ending each time.
| Year | Source | Wording |
|---|---|---|
| 1592 | Greene's Groats-worth of Witte | "an absolute Johannes fac totum" |
| 1618 | Geffray Minshull, Essayes and Characters of a Prison and Prisoners | "hath plaid Iack of all trades" |
| About 1677 | Martin Clifford, notes on Dryden's poems | "like a Jack of all Trades Shop, they have Variety, but nothing of value" |
| 1721 | The Boston News-Letter, per the Oxford English Dictionary as cited by Wikipedia | "Jack of all Trades; and it would seem, Good at none" |
| 1732 | A proverb collection | "Jack of all trades is of no trade" |
| 1741 | Charles Lucas, Pharmacomastix | "a Jack of all trades, and in truth, master of none" |
| 21st century | No known author | "but oftentimes better than a master of one" |
The 1741 pamphlet behind master of none
The Phrase Finder names Charles Lucas's Pharmacomastix as the earliest printed example of the exact words and dates it to 1785. The date is too late. Lucas died in 1771, and the Wellcome Collection holds a copy printed in Dublin in 1741. Its scanned text contains the passage, so "master of none" is at least 44 years older than the usual account says.
Lucas was an apothecary attacking his own trade. In other countries, he wrote, a druggist was a drug merchant. At home the same man played physician, surgeon, apothecary and seller of paints and poisons, "a Jack of all trades, and in truth, master of none".
What does jack of all trades mean today?
The two halves now carry different weights. Merriam-Webster defines a jack-of-all-trades as "a person who can do passable work at various tasks" and "a handy versatile person". It defines the longer phrase as "a person who can do many things but is not an expert in any of them".
Used alone, the first half is neutral or friendly. With "master of none" attached it is a criticism. Wiktionary records a female form, Jill of all trades.
Is jack of all trades an insult or a compliment?
It depends on the work. Where depth is the whole job, as in surgery, nobody wants a jack of all trades. On a small team that needs one person to handle the website, the invoices and the customers, range is the qualification.
David Epstein makes the strongest modern case for range. In his 2019 book of that name he argues that in complex and unpredictable fields, generalists are better placed to excel than early specialists. His examples are some of the most successful athletes, musicians and scientists in the world, a much higher bar than "passable work at various tasks". Our comparison of the generalist vs specialist paths weighs both sides, and T-shaped skills describes the usual compromise of a broad base with one deep specialty.
The invented ending does say something true about how people feel. Many who are called a jack of all trades hear an accusation and want an answer. They have a fair one without the fake history. A generalist who can connect several fields does work that a narrow expert cannot do.
Where Generalist fits
Generalist is an iPhone app for the first half of the phrase. It has 244 topics across 16 subjects, taught in lessons of 3 to 7 minutes that list their sources. It will not make you a master of any of them, and it does not claim to. You can sample it with a random short lesson.
Common questions
What is the full quote of jack of all trades, master of none?
The widely shared version is "A jack of all trades is a master of none, but oftentimes better than a master of one." Only the first two parts are historical. "Jack of all trades" dates from 1618 and "master of none" from 1741. The final line is a 21st-century addition.
Did Shakespeare say jack of all trades?
No. The phrase appears nowhere in his plays or poems. In 1592 a pamphlet published under Robert Greene's name mocked a new playwright, almost certainly Shakespeare, as "an absolute Johannes fac totum". That Latin tag means roughly "Johnny do-everything" and is the nearest the phrase comes to him.
Who first said jack of all trades?
The earliest known use in print is by Geffray Minshull in Essayes and Characters of a Prison and Prisoners, published in 1618. He described a prison porter as "some broken Citizen, who hath plaid Iack of all trades". Minshull wrote the essays while jailed for debt.
Is being a jack of all trades a good thing?
Often, yes. Small teams, new companies and unpredictable jobs reward people who can handle varied work. The risk is staying shallow everywhere. A common answer is to keep the range and add one skill you know deeply, a profile sometimes called T-shaped.
What is the female version of jack of all trades?
Jill of all trades. Wiktionary records the full form as "Jill of all trades, mistress of none". In practice, jack of all trades is used for anyone, in the same way that Jack once stood for any ordinary person in English sayings.
Sources
- Jack of all trades: meaning and origin of the phrase, The Phrase Finder
- Jack-of-all-trades: definition and first known use, Merriam-Webster
- Jack-of-all-trades, master of none: definition, Merriam-Webster
- jack of all trades, master of none, Wiktionary
- Jack of all trades, Wikipedia
- Minshull, Geffray, in the Dictionary of National Biography, 1885-1900, Wikisource
- Pharmacomastix, or, The office, use, and abuse of apothecaries explained, by Charles Lucas (Dublin, 1741), Wellcome Collection
- Charles Lucas, Royal College of Physicians Museum
- Greene's Groats-Worth of Wit, Wikipedia
- Factotum: definition and etymology, Merriam-Webster
- The Complete Works of William Shakespeare, Project Gutenberg
- Quote attributed to William Shakespeare, marked as not verified, Goodreads
- Range: Why Generalists Triumph in a Specialized World, David Epstein