Mathematics & Logic · Numbers & patterns

Percentages and why the base matters

See why a 20% fall takes a 25% rise to undo, why 5% to 10% is both five points and a doubling, and why you can't average two percentages.

4 short lessons · about 21 minutes · 4 sources · updated November 2026

What you will learn

  • Calculate a percentage of a clearly identified whole
  • Explain why reversing a change takes a different percentage
  • Find the base a percentage claim uses, and spot wording that hides it
  • Distinguish a percentage-point difference from a relative percentage change
  • Calculate the result of successive percentage changes, each on its own base
  • Choose between points and relative change to fit the decision a reader faces

Lesson 1 of 4 · 6 min

Why a 20% cut takes a 25% rise to undo

Before you readAn item's price drops from 100 euros to 60 euros. The old price was what percentage higher than the new price?

Correct.Not quite. The answer is About 67%.

The old price was about 67% higher than the new one, even though the price was cut by 40%. This lesson is about why both numbers are honest.

Say a shop cuts a price by 20%. A week later it raises the new price by 20%. The price doesn't return to where it started.

The reason is in the word itself. Percent means per hundred, so 20% is 20 out of 100, or one fifth. But one fifth of what? A percentage compares an amount with a reference whole, called the base. Until you know the base, you can't tell how many euros or people the percentage stands for.

Say a jacket costs 80 euros. Twenty percent of 80 is 0.20 times 80, which is 16 euros, so the reduced price is 64 euros. Another jacket starts at 200 euros, and the same 20% removes 40 euros.

The percentage is the same. The amount differs because the base differs. So always keep a percentage attached to its base.

Check yourselfA price falls from 80 euros to 64 euros. What amount is the 20% discount measured against?

Correct.Not quite. The answer is The original price of 80 euros.

The 16-euro reduction is one fifth of the original 80 euros. Measuring it against the final price, or treating the 16 euros as the base, answers a different question.

Now raise the 64-euro price by 20%, as the shop did. Twenty percent of 64 is only 12.80, so the price lands at 76.80 euros, short of 80.

Getting all the way back takes 16 euros, and the base is now 64. Dividing 16 by 64 gives 0.25. So a 20% decrease takes a 25% increase to reverse. The euros match and the percentages differ, because the base changed from 80 to 64.

The same rule works for things other than prices. A club that grows from 40 members to 50 gains 10 on its original 40, a 25% rise. Going back from 50 to 40 loses 10 out of 50, a 20% fall.

These examples start from positive amounts. You can't find a percentage change from zero, because there's no starting amount to divide by.

Try to recallA club falls from 50 members to 40, then grows back to 50. Why are the two percentage changes different when each one involves 10 people?

The fall uses 50 as its base, so 10 divided by 50 is 20%. The rise uses 40, so 10 divided by 40 is 25%.

In everyday wording, the base hides behind a short phrase. The answer to "percent of what?" usually follows the word "of," as in "20% of the original price." Comparisons tuck it into other phrases. "Higher than last year" makes last year the base, and "of those surveyed" makes the respondents the base. When a claim has no such phrase at all, as in "sales are up 30%," the base has simply been left out, and the number can't be checked.

Two honest sentences about the same pair of numbers can sound as if they disagree. Say an item goes from 100 euros to 60. Against the old price, the cut is 40 out of 100, so one notice says 40% off.

Against the new price, the old one was 40 euros higher, and 40 divided by 60 is about 0.667. So another notice says the old price was about 67% higher. Neither has miscalculated. They've chosen different bases.

This is a habit more than a rule to memorize. Before you accept or repeat a percentage, say the full sentence, "this amount, compared with this whole." If you can't fill in the second half from what you were told, a piece of information is missing. No calculation will supply it.

It's also the fastest way to compare two claims. Once both bases are written down, the numbers usually stop contradicting each other.

Check yourselfA price moves from 100 euros to 60 euros. One notice says the price was cut by 40%, and another says the old price was about 67% higher than the new one. Which assessment is right?

Correct.Not quite. The answer is Both are correct, because the first compares the cut with 100 and the second compares it with 60.

The change is 40 euros in both sentences. Only the whole it's compared with differs. Dividing 40 by the original 100 gives 40%, and dividing 40 by the new 60 gives about 67%. A change has no single correct percentage until you say which amount it's measured against.

A 20% cut takes a 25% rise to undo, because each percentage is measured from its own starting amount. So before you trust a percentage, ask one question. Percent of what?

Lessons in this topic

  1. Why a 20% cut takes a 25% rise to undo

    Find the whole a percentage is taken from, and see why the same change gets a different percentage in each direction.

    Essentials · 6 min

  2. Why 5% to 10% is five points and also a 100% rise

    Tell percentage points apart from relative change, and track several changes in a row.

    Essentials · 5 min

  3. Why you can't average two percentages

    Combine group percentages by counting the people behind them, and see how every group can improve while the total gets worse.

    Deeper · 5 min

  4. Undo a percentage change by dividing

    Recover an original amount from a final one by dividing by the multiplier, then reverse a whole sequence of changes.

    Deeper · 5 min

Three quick stories from this topic

A 50% fall needs a 100% rise

A price that falls 50% has to rise 100% to get back to where it started

Halve 80 euros and you have 40. A 50% rise on 40 adds only 20, because the percentage is now taken from the smaller amount. Getting back to 80 means adding another 40, which is 100% of what's left.

The base moved

A percentage change is measured against the amount you start from. After the fall that amount is half as big, so each percent is worth half as many euros.

Smaller falls do it too

A 20% fall needs a 25% rise to undo it, and a 25% fall needs a rise of about 33%. The gap widens as the fall gets deeper.

8% of 50 equals 50% of 8

8% of 50 is the same as 50% of 8, so a hard percentage often has an easy twin

Finding a percent of a number is a multiplication, and multiplying gives the same answer in either order. So 40% of 75 is 75% of 40, which is 30. The swap works for a share of an amount, never for a percentage change.

"Percent of" means multiply

A percent of a number is the decimal form of the percent times the base, so a 20% tip on 80 is 0.20 times 80. In the same way, 40% of 75 is 0.40 times 75, and 75% of 40 is 0.75 times 40. The commutative property of multiplication says a times b equals b times a, so both products are 30.

The swap works for a share, not for a change

Swapping is only safe when you want a percentage of an amount. A percentage change is measured against its starting amount, so 40% more than 75, which is 105, isn't the same claim as 75% more than 40, which is 70.

Berkeley's admissions paradox

Berkeley's 1973 admissions favored men overall while most big departments favored women

Across the graduate school, 44% of men who applied were admitted and 35% of women. But women had applied more often to departments that turned most applicants away. In four of the six largest departments, their admission rate was the higher one.

Simpson's paradox

A pattern in a combined figure can reverse inside the groups that make it up. Statisticians call this Simpson's paradox.

Why the total misleads

An overall percentage is a weighted average. The men's total leaned on departments that admitted most applicants, and the women's on departments that admitted few.

Sources

This topic is part of From everyday numbers to proof, a guided path through related topics.

  • When the average is the wrong summary

    When one number stands in for a whole set, which number you pick changes the story. Mean, median and mode tend to pull apart when the shape is lopsided.

    4 lessons · 20 min

  • Fractions and decimals

    A fraction is a number, a division and a share all at once. See why adding needs a common denominator and multiplying doesn't, and why some fractions become decimals that never end.

    4 lessons · 16 min

  • Prime numbers

    Primes can't be split into smaller factors, and every whole number is built from them in exactly one way. See how to find them, why they never run out, and why online security relies on them.

    4 lessons · 16 min

  • Scale, area and volume

    See why doubling a shape's size can mean four times the covering and eight times the filling, and why the answer changes when only one dimension grows.

    4 lessons · 16 min

  • What an expected value promises

    An expected value is the average you'd get over many repetitions. See how to calculate one, why it can be a result that never happens, and what it can't tell you about a single try.

    4 lessons · 20 min

  • Sets and Venn diagrams

    A set is a collection with a clear rule for what belongs. Learn union, intersection and complement, draw them as overlapping circles, and use them to count survey answers and build search queries.

    4 lessons · 16 min

All mathematics & logic topics · Take the quiz