Body & Health · Mental health
Treating panic disorder, and judging a therapy
Panic disorder is typically treated with talk therapy, medication or both. Exposure therapy lowers fear a little at a time, each medicine has its own trade-off, and no regulator checks a therapy's evidence before you're offered it.

What you will learn
- Describe what psychotherapy is and the three goals NIMH gives it.
- Explain why NIMH advises a medical check before starting psychotherapy.
- Describe how exposure therapy brings a fear down over time.
- Say what interoceptive exposure targets and how that differs from other exposure.
Lesson 1 of 4 · 5 min
What talk therapy is for, and why a checkup comes first
Say someone's panic attacks have dropped from several a week to one a month. They still won't drive, and they've stopped seeing friends. Has therapy worked?
Only partly, by therapy's own standard. The US National Institute of Mental Health, or NIMH, gives psychotherapy three goals. They're relief from symptoms, maintaining or improving daily functioning, and a better quality of life. Fewer attacks is progress on the first. How a person gets through ordinary days counts separately.
Psychotherapy is also called talk therapy. It covers a variety of treatments that help a person identify and change troubling emotions, thoughts and behaviors. Most of it happens one-on-one with a licensed mental health professional or in a group. For panic disorder it can work in person or by telehealth.
What happens in a session depends on the approach. In cognitive behavioral therapy, or CBT, a person learns to notice automatic thoughts that are inaccurate or harmful, question them and change self-defeating behavior. Other elements of therapy include problem-solving for stress, breathing exercises, and tracking emotions and behavior to see how each affects the other.
People come to therapy for many reasons. Severe or long-term stress is one. The loss of a loved one is another. A third is having symptoms with no physical explanation, such as changes in sleep or appetite, low energy, persistent irritability or excessive worry.
But a symptom only counts as having no physical explanation once someone has looked for one. So NIMH advises a medical exam first. A change in mood or trouble concentrating is sometimes due to a medical condition, and an exam can help rule that out.
Panic disorder shows why. An attack can feel like a heart attack, with a racing heart, chest pain and difficulty breathing. After discussing a person's history, a provider may do a physical exam to make sure an unrelated physical problem isn't causing the symptoms.
Both can also be true at once. Some people with panic disorder also have heart disease, breathing disorders or thyroid problems.
Try to recallWhy does NIMH advise being examined by a health care provider before starting psychotherapy?
Because symptoms such as a change in mood or trouble concentrating are sometimes due to a medical condition, and an exam can help rule out a physical health issue. A symptom only counts as having no physical explanation once someone has looked for one. For panic disorder, a provider may do a physical exam after discussing the person's history, to make sure an unrelated physical problem isn't causing the symptoms.
So therapy is judged on three things, and having fewer symptoms is only the first. If you're worried about your own mental health, NIMH suggests starting with a primary care provider. They can refer you to a psychologist, psychiatrist or clinical social worker, who can help you figure out the next steps.
Lessons in this topic
What talk therapy is for, and why a checkup comes first
Talk therapy aims at more than fewer symptoms. A medical exam can come before it, because a physical problem can cause the same symptoms.
How facing a fear in small doses shrinks it
Exposure therapy has a person face a feared thing in brief, supported periods until the fear drops. For panic disorder, the feared thing can be the body's own sensations.
Why no agency approves a talk therapy
In the US, medicines need FDA approval and psychotherapies don't. That leaves the questions about a therapy's evidence to the person choosing it.
The trade-offs of panic medicines, and what therapy adds
Each of the three types of medicine used for panic disorder has its own trade-off, and therapy can still help once a medicine is working.
Three quick stories from this topic
Bringing on panic sensations
One therapy for panic disorder brings on the sensations of an attack on purpose
It's called interoceptive exposure. Exercises such as spinning, holding the breath or breathing through a straw are designed to produce sensations like those of a panic attack. Deliberate, repeated exposure is thought to help the fear of those sensations wear off.
Why aim at sensations
Someone with panic disorder might feel their heart pounding and assume it's a heart attack. That reading adds fear, which may lead to a vicious cycle.
Part of a wider therapy
Interoceptive exposure is a technique within cognitive behavioral therapy, which NIMH calls the gold standard choice of psychotherapy. It may be used along with relaxation exercises and breathing training.
Fast relief, kept brief
A medicine that calms panic attacks fast may be prescribed only for brief periods
Benzodiazepines can rapidly decrease panic attack symptoms. But some people build up a tolerance and need higher and higher doses for the same effect, and some become dependent on them.
Antidepressants take weeks to start
SSRI and SNRI antidepressants can also help treat panic disorder symptoms. They may take several weeks to start working, and their side effects are usually not severe.
Therapy can work alongside them
Even when medication relieves symptoms, psychotherapy can help with specific issues, such as self-defeating ways of thinking or irrational fears.
No approval process for therapy
No US agency approves a talk therapy the way the FDA approves a medicine
Medications go through the Food and Drug Administration's formal approval process. A psychotherapy can be offered under its own name with no agency weighing its evidence first, so asking about that evidence falls to the person choosing it.
The evidence still exists
For many therapies, research involving large numbers of patients has provided evidence that they work. These evidence-based therapies have been shown to reduce symptoms of depression, anxiety and other mental disorders.
So the questions fall to you
NIMH suggests asking a prospective therapist what the rationale for the therapy is, what its evidence base is, and how progress will be assessed.
Sources
- Panic Disorder: What You Need to Know, National Institute of Mental Health
- Psychotherapies, National Institute of Mental Health
- Interoceptive hypersensitivity and interoceptive exposure in patients with panic disorder: specificity and effectiveness, BMC Psychiatry (Lee et al., 2006)





