Guide · Ways of learning
What is a generalist species?
A generalist species is an animal or plant that can eat many kinds of food and live in many kinds of habitat. Raccoons, coyotes, rats and crows are common examples. The opposite is a specialist species, such as the koala, which depends on a narrow diet or a single type of habitat.
The difference matters most when the environment changes. Ecologists have found that generalists are spreading while specialists decline, and cities are a good place to see why.
Generalist species definition in biology
National Geographic's education library puts it plainly. Generalists "can eat a variety of foods and thrive in a range of habitats". Specialists "have a limited diet and stricter habitat requirements". The label describes which food and habitat resources a species relies on to survive.
Most species fall between the two extremes. Biologists treat specialization as a scale that runs from the strictest specialists, which eat one type of food, to the broadest generalists. Omnivores usually sit near the generalist end.
What is niche breadth?
An ecological niche is the role a species plays in its community. Britannica defines it as all of a species' interactions with the other members of that community, shaped also by conditions such as soil type and climate.
Niche breadth is how wide that role is. A species with a broad niche tolerates a wide range of temperatures, foods and nesting sites. A species with a narrow niche needs particular conditions and fails without them. Generalist is the everyday word for a broad niche, and specialist for a narrow one.
Examples of generalist species
- Raccoon. It lives from southern Canada to northern South America, in forests, farmland, suburbs and cities, and has spread through parts of Europe and Asia after being introduced. The University of Michigan's Animal Diversity Web calls it "omnivorous and opportunistic". Its diet runs from fruit, nuts and corn to crayfish, frogs, bird eggs and household trash.
- Coyote. It hunts hares and deer, eats carrion, and switches to wild berries and fruit when prey is scarce. A 2018 paper in ZooKeys reports that coyotes have expanded their range by an estimated 40 percent since the 1950s, at least twice as much as any other North American carnivore. They now live from Alaska to Panama.
- Brown rat. Britannica describes it as highly adaptable and found on every continent except Antarctica. It eats shrimp, snails, insects, bird eggs, fish, carrion, seeds and plants.
- American crow. The Cornell Lab of Ornithology says it eats "a vast array of foods", including grain, fruit, earthworms, mice, fish, the eggs of other birds, carrion and garbage. It uses farmland, landfills, city parks and beaches.
- German cockroach. It is found almost worldwide, and cold is its main limit. Alongside human food it has been recorded eating soap, toothpaste and glue.
Examples of specialist species
- Koala. It feeds selectively on the leaves of certain eucalyptus trees and cannot live on even closely related trees. Gut bacteria break down the toxins in the leaves.
- Giant panda. Bamboo makes up as much as 90 to 98 percent of its diet, according to Britannica. The panda kept the gut of its meat-eating ancestors and digests bamboo poorly, so it can spend 16 hours a day eating.
- Canada lynx. It preys on the snowshoe hare and lives in the snowy forests where the hare lives.
- Monarch butterfly. The adults drink nectar from many flowers, but they breed only where milkweed grows, because milkweed is the plant their caterpillars eat.
Generalist vs specialist species
The monarch shows why the labels need care. One life stage is a generalist and the other a specialist, and the specialist stage sets the limit for the species.
| Trait | Generalist species | Specialist species |
|---|---|---|
| Diet | Many foods, often omnivorous | One food or a few |
| Habitat | Many habitats, often including towns | One habitat type |
| Response to change | Switches food or moves | Declines if its food or habitat goes |
| Competition | Shares its foods with many other species | Faces fewer rivals for its own resource |
| Examples | Raccoon, coyote, brown rat, American crow | Koala, giant panda, Canada lynx |
Why do generalists cope better with habitat change?
A generalist has a fallback. When a coyote cannot find hares it eats fruit. When a forest becomes a suburb, a raccoon dens in a garage or a storm drain and eats from the bins. A specialist has no second option. Britannica records that mass die-offs of bamboo have brought starvation to some panda populations. Koala numbers fell by nearly 28 percent between 1984 and 2012, largely because of habitat loss and fragmentation.
The pattern holds at global scale. Joanne Clavel, Romain Julliard and Vincent Devictor reviewed the evidence in Frontiers in Ecology and the Environment. They concluded that specialist species are declining worldwide, that niche theory predicts this, and that generalists are replacing them in many places. They called the result "functional homogenization", meaning that communities in different places come to hold the same kinds of species.
The coyote shows the mechanism. The ZooKeys study found that its spread began around 1900 and was probably helped by forest fragmentation and the removal of larger predators. Changes that hurt other mammals opened space for it.
Generalist species and urbanization
A city is habitat change at its most extreme, with new foods, new shelters and few of the old ones. A 2023 study in Nature Communications examined 5,302 animal species in 379 cities on six continents. Its authors note that cosmopolitan generalists are found in most cities while specialists tend to disappear, and that cities tend to favor small, mobile animals with a broad niche and a generalist diet.
The same study is a warning against simple stories. It found four different sets of traits among urban animals, and two of the four describe specialists. The authors say the evidence that city wildlife is becoming uniform worldwide is still inconclusive.
What are the trade-offs of being a generalist species?
If generalists handle change so well, the question is why specialists exist. The answer is that specializing pays when conditions hold steady. A narrow niche means fewer competitors. The koala's long gut and its bacteria let it live on eucalyptus leaves, which are full of tannins and other toxic substances. A generalist takes a little from many sources and competes with every other generalist that eats the same things.
Ecology has its own version of the jack of all trades, master of none trade-off. The generalist is rarely the best at using any one resource. It survives because it is seldom the worst when a resource disappears.
Generalists can also become a problem. The traits that let raccoons and brown rats live anywhere are the traits that help them spread once people carry them to a new continent.
Where Generalist fits
The app Generalist takes its name from the human meaning of the word, which our guide to what a generalist is explains, along with how it compares with specialist careers. Science is one of the app's 16 subjects, and its lessons take 3 to 7 minutes and list their sources. For more like the cockroach and the toothpaste, try the interesting facts page.
Common questions
What is an example of a generalist species?
The raccoon is the standard example. It lives in forests, farmland and cities across North America and eats fruit, nuts, insects, frogs, eggs and human trash. Coyotes, brown rats, American crows and German cockroaches are also generalists, because each one uses many foods and many habitats.
What is the difference between a generalist and a specialist species?
A generalist species uses many foods and habitats, so it can switch when one runs short. A specialist species depends on a narrow diet or habitat, as the koala depends on eucalyptus. Specialists face less competition for their resource but suffer more when the environment changes.
Can a species be both a generalist and a specialist?
Yes. The labels mark the ends of a scale, and a species can sit at different points for diet and habitat or at different life stages. Adult monarch butterflies drink nectar from many flowers, but their caterpillars eat only milkweed, so monarchs breed only where milkweed grows.
Is the giant panda a specialist species?
Yes. Bamboo makes up as much as 90 to 98 percent of a giant panda's diet, and the Smithsonian's National Zoo calls it a highly specialized animal. Destruction of its forest habitat, combined with poaching, has confined wild pandas to fragments of mountain forest in central China.
Why are specialist species more at risk of extinction?
A specialist has no substitute when its food or habitat is lost. Habitat destruction and climate change remove exactly the narrow conditions it needs. A review by Clavel and colleagues found specialist species declining worldwide while generalists replace them, a result that niche theory predicts.
Sources
- Generalist and Specialist Species, National Geographic Society
- Generalist and specialist species, Wikipedia
- Niche (ecology), Encyclopaedia Britannica
- Worldwide decline of specialist species: toward a global functional homogenization? (Clavel, Julliard and Devictor), Frontiers in Ecology and the Environment
- Urbanisation generates multiple trait syndromes for terrestrial animal taxa worldwide (Hahs et al., Nature Communications, 2023), PubMed Central
- Mapping the expansion of coyotes (Canis latrans) across North and Central America (Hody and Kays, ZooKeys, 2018), PubMed Central
- Procyon lotor (raccoon), Animal Diversity Web, University of Michigan
- Coyote, Encyclopaedia Britannica
- Brown rat, Encyclopaedia Britannica
- American Crow life history, Cornell Lab of Ornithology, All About Birds
- Blattella germanica (German cockroach), Animal Diversity Web, University of Michigan
- Koala, Encyclopaedia Britannica
- Giant panda, Encyclopaedia Britannica
- Giant panda, Smithsonian's National Zoo and Conservation Biology Institute
- Monarch Butterfly Habitat Needs, US Forest Service