Guide · Learning science
What is active recall?
Active recall is a study method in which you pull information out of memory instead of looking at it again. You close the book and answer a question, write down what you remember, or explain the idea aloud. Researchers call the practice retrieval practice and its benefit the testing effect.
It is among the best-supported study methods and among the least used. In surveys, most students say they reread instead.
Active recall vs passive review
Passive review means taking the material in again. Active recall means producing it yourself. The difference matters because a page you have just reread looks familiar, and familiarity is easy to mistake for knowledge.
| Point of comparison | Passive review | Active recall |
|---|---|---|
| What you do | Reread, highlight, watch again | Answer from memory, then check |
| How it feels | Smooth and reassuring | Effortful, with gaps on show |
| What it tells you | That the page looks familiar | What you can and cannot produce |
| Score on a test minutes later | Slightly higher | Slightly lower |
| Score on a test a week later | Clearly lower | Clearly higher |
What does the research say about active recall?
The last two rows of that table come from a 2006 study in Psychological Science by Henry Roediger and Jeffrey Karpicke. Students at Washington University read a short prose passage. One group studied it in four study periods. Another studied it once and then wrote down everything they could remember, three times over, with no feedback. Among students tested five minutes later, the rereaders recalled 83 percent of the ideas and the recall group 71 percent. Among students tested a week later, the order reversed. The recall group remembered 61 percent and the rereaders 40 percent, although the rereaders had read the passage about 14 times and the recall group about 3 times.
Recall also beat a more elaborate method. In a 2011 paper in Science, Karpicke and Janell Blunt had 80 undergraduates learn a science text in one of four ways. One group drew concept maps with the text open. Another read, recalled, reread and recalled again. A week later, on questions that tested both facts and inferences, the recall group averaged 67 percent and the concept-mapping group 45 percent. The students had predicted the opposite, expecting repeated reading to work best and recall worst. In a second experiment, 101 of 120 students did better with recall than with concept mapping.
A 2013 review by John Dunlosky and four colleagues assessed ten common study techniques. Practice testing was one of two rated high utility. Rereading and highlighting were rated low.
Students rarely predict any of this. In the 2006 study the rereaders were the most confident. In a 2009 survey of 177 college students by Karpicke, Andrew Butler and Roediger, a majority said they reread their notes or textbook and relatively few tested themselves.
How to do active recall
Any activity counts if the answer comes out of your head before it comes off the page. Four methods cover most situations.
- Flashcards. Put a question on the front and answer it, aloud or on paper, before you turn the card. Turning it early converts recall into rereading.
- Blank-page recall. After a chapter or lecture, close everything and write down what you remember for a few minutes. Then open the source and mark what you missed or got wrong.
- Practice questions. Use end-of-chapter questions, past papers or a quiz. Questions that make you produce an answer do more than questions that let you recognize one. A 2014 meta-analysis by Christopher Rowland found larger benefits from recall tests than from recognition tests.
- Teaching. Explain the idea to someone, or to an empty room, without notes. In a 2018 experiment by Aloysius Koh and colleagues, students who taught from memory did as well a week later as students who practiced retrieval, and better than students who taught with notes in hand. The Feynman technique is a structured version of this.
An active recall study method, step by step
This routine works for a textbook chapter, a lecture or a long article.
- Read or listen once, for understanding. Leave the highlighter alone.
- Close the source. Write down everything you can remember, in any order, for three to five minutes.
- Open the source and compare. Mark what you missed and what you got wrong.
- Turn each miss into a question and keep the questions in a list or on cards.
- Answer those questions the next day without looking, and again a few days after that.
Active recall and spaced repetition
Recall once and you learn something. Recall again after a gap and you keep it. Spaced repetition is the scheduling half of the pair. In a 2011 experiment by Karpicke and Althea Bauernschmidt, repeated recall with long intervals between attempts produced a 200 percent improvement in long-term retention over repeated recall with no spacing.
A workable rhythm is to recall the same day, again within a few days, and again a week or two later. Keep testing items you already got right. In a 2008 study in Science, Karpicke and Roediger found that once students could recall a foreign vocabulary word, further study did nothing for delayed recall, while further testing had a large positive effect.
Common active recall mistakes
- Peeking. If you look at the answer after two seconds, you are rereading with a short delay. Commit to an answer first.
- Skipping the check. Recall without checking leaves your errors in place. Compare against the source every time.
- Starting too early. You need something to retrieve, so read for understanding first. Arthur Gates's classroom experiments in 1917 already suggested that some study has to come before recitation pays off.
- Stopping at the first success. One correct answer today says little about next month.
- Asking only for facts. Add questions that begin with why and how. In Andrew Butler's 2010 experiments, repeated testing improved answers to new inference questions as well as to repeated ones.
- Judging by feel. Rereading feels productive and recall feels like failing. The week-later results run the other way.
What active recall cannot do
Recall strengthens what you have understood. It does little for a text you never followed in the first place, and it is slower per session than rereading. Some researchers also argue that the advantage shrinks for very complex, tightly connected material, a claim that others dispute. Our testing effect guide covers that debate. For most of what people want to remember from books, courses and lectures, the evidence favors recall.
Try it with Generalist
Generalist: Micro Learning builds recall into its lessons. Each lesson opens with a question and checks understanding with questions, and questions from lessons you completed return later in short review sessions. Lessons take 3 to 7 minutes, and you can browse all 16 subjects on the site first.
Common questions
What is the active recall study method?
Active recall is studying by retrieving information from memory instead of reviewing it. You answer questions, write what you remember on a blank page, or explain a topic without notes, then check against the source. Psychologists call it retrieval practice.
Is active recall better than rereading?
For long-term memory, yes. In Roediger and Karpicke's 2006 experiment, students who recalled a passage three times remembered 61 percent of it a week later, against 40 percent for students who reread it. Rereading did slightly better only on a test five minutes after study.
How do you combine active recall and spaced repetition?
Test yourself on the material the same day, again a few days later, and again after a week or two. Flashcard apps automate this by showing each card at growing intervals. Recall supplies the method and spacing supplies the timing.
Does active recall work for understanding or only for memorizing?
It helps with both. Karpicke and Blunt's 2011 study in Science found that retrieval practice improved answers to inference questions, and Butler's 2010 experiments found gains on new questions that required applying what was learned. Recall still depends on understanding the material first.
Sources
- Test-enhanced learning: Taking memory tests improves long-term retention (Roediger and Karpicke, 2006), Psychological Science, copy hosted by the Purdue Cognition and Learning Lab
- Retrieval practice produces more learning than elaborative studying with concept mapping (Karpicke and Blunt, 2011), Science, copy hosted by the Purdue Cognition and Learning Lab
- Improving students' learning with effective learning techniques (Dunlosky, Rawson, Marsh, Nathan and Willingham, 2013), Psychological Science in the Public Interest
- Metacognitive strategies in student learning: Do students practise retrieval when they study on their own? (Karpicke, Butler and Roediger, 2009), Memory
- The effect of testing versus restudy on retention: A meta-analytic review of the testing effect (Rowland, 2014), Psychological Bulletin
- The learning benefits of teaching: A retrieval practice hypothesis (Koh, Lee and Lim, 2018), Applied Cognitive Psychology
- Spaced retrieval: Absolute spacing enhances learning regardless of relative spacing (Karpicke and Bauernschmidt, 2011), Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, and Cognition
- The critical importance of retrieval for learning (Karpicke and Roediger, 2008), Science
- Repeated testing produces superior transfer of learning relative to repeated studying (Butler, 2010), Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, and Cognition
- The power of testing memory: Basic research and implications for educational practice (Roediger and Karpicke, 2006), Perspectives on Psychological Science, copy hosted by the Purdue Cognition and Learning Lab